Are natural lipids UV-screening agents?

Isolated lipids from Deinococcus radiodurans were reconstituted at final concentrations of 1 mg/ml into dioleoyl phosphatidyl choline (DOPC) vesicles and assayed for the ability to protect cells of Escherichia coli against killing by UV light (254 nm). Values of D₃₇ (UV dose required to reduce the number of surviving cells to 37% of the original number) were calculated from killing curves. E. coli was afforded the greatest protection with an individual lipid, identified as vitamin MK8 (D₃₇=310 J//m², compared to D₃₇=67 J/m² for E. coli irradiated in the presence of DOPC alone). Liposome-mediated protection was dependent on UV₂₅₄ absorbance and not on turbidity-related light-scattering. BOth vitamin MK8 from D. radiodurans and vitamin K₁, which is available commercially, showed a similar degree of UV₂₅₄-protection for E. coli. The UV-protective properties of vitamin K₁ were also investigated on mammalian cells in comparison with other natural lipids and known sunscreens. Survival curves were obtained for mouse fibroblast (L) cells irradiated at UV₂₅₄ in the absence or presence of DOPC liposomes into which were incorporated various natural lipids or standard sunscreen ingredients, all at final concentrations of 1 mg/ml. Experimentally determined values of D₃₇ were as follows: Vitamin K₁, 73 J/m²; \-carotene, 44 J/m₂; α-tocopherol, 20 J/m₂; sulisobenzone, 156 J/m²; p-aminobenzoic acid (PABA), 113 J/m²; benzophenone, 80 J/m²; oxybenzone, 61 J/m² and DOPC alone. 23 J/m². Vitamin K₁, the most protective lipid tested, was also compared with PABA and oxybenzone (all at concentrations of 20 mg/ml; applied topicall) for its ability to protec Skh-hairless mice from UV₂₅₄-induced erythema, yielding a UV₂₅₄ protection factor of 3.5. In addition, vitamin K₁ (at 100 mg/ml) was able to provide hairless mice with a small degree of UVB protection, as indicated by an experimentally determined Solar Protection Factor of 1.5-2.0. Although it is concluded that vitamin K is not likely to account for the extraordinarily high degree of UV-resistance of D. radiodurans, vitamin K does show characteristics worthy of its consideration as a UV-screening agent.