Medical Need: Evaluating a Conceptual Critique of Universal Health Coverage

Résultat de recherche: Articleexamen par les pairs

7 Citations (Scopus)

Résumé

Some argue that the concept of medical need is inadequate to inform the design of a universal health care system—particularly an institutional (universal, comprehensive) rather than a residual (minimalist, safety net) system. They argue that the concept (a) contradicts the idea of comprehensiveness; (b) leads to unsustainable expenditures; (c) is too indeterminate for policy; and (d) supports only a prioritarian distribution (and therefore a residual system). I argue (a) that ‘comprehensive’ understood as ‘including the full continuum of care’ and ‘medically necessary’ understood as ‘prioritized by medical criteria’ are not contradictory, and (b) that UHC is a solution to the problem of sustainability, not its cause. Those who criticize ‘medical need’ for indeterminacy (c) are not transparent about the source (ethical, semantic, political, or other) of their commitment to their standards of determinacy: they promote standards that are higher than is necessary for legitimate policy, ignoring opportunity costs. Furthermore, the indeterminacy of concepts affects all risk-sharing systems and all systems that rely on medical standard of care. I then argue that (d) the concept of need in itself does not imply a minimal sufficientist standard or a prioritarian distribution; neither does the idea of legitimate public policy dictate that public services be minimalist. The policy choice for a system of health care that is comprehensive and offers as good care as can be achieved when delivered on equal terms and conditions for all is a coherent option.

Langue d'origineEnglish
Pages (de-à)114-137
Nombre de pages24
JournalHealth Care Analysis
Volume25
Numéro de publication2
DOI
Statut de publicationPublished - juin 1 2017

Note bibliographique

Publisher Copyright:
© 2016, Springer Science+Business Media New York.

ASJC Scopus Subject Areas

  • Issues, ethics and legal aspects
  • Health(social science)
  • Health Policy

Empreinte numérique

Plonger dans les sujets de recherche 'Medical Need: Evaluating a Conceptual Critique of Universal Health Coverage'. Ensemble, ils forment une empreinte numérique unique.

Citer